Connect with us

Featured

Op-Ed: Civilians Should Oversee the Police

Published

on

By Larry C. White

 

Jerry Brown was mayor of Oakland in 2003 when the Oakland Police Department was put under the supervision of federal Judge Thelton Henderson as fallout from the “Riders” scandal.

 

 

Brown long ago moved on to Sacramento, but Judge Henderson still oversees the OPD, which has been unable to comply with the reforms he ordered.

 

Reform was supposed to take no more than five years. It’s been 13 years, and the job is still not done.

 

Oakland has so far spent more than $30 million to pay for a federal monitor and compliance director. Yet federal oversight has not stopped police misconduct.

 

In the past 13 years, Oakland has paid at least $70 million to settle lawsuits based on the actions of OPD officers. The human toll of police misconduct can’t be reduced to numbers and it has got to stop.

 

Since 2003, there have been four mayors, eight city administrators, and five police chiefs (seven if you count the two that came and went in a week in June). None of them have reformed the police. Most of them didn’t even try.

 

This clearly isn’t just an Oakland Police Department problem–it’s an Oakland city government problem.

 

There is finally a chance to break Oakland’s cycle of indifference to police reform. It’s called Measure LL.

 

Although it was put on the November ballot by the City Council in a unanimous vote, Measure LL is largely the product of a group of concerned citizens from diverse backgrounds working under the name “Coalition for Police Accountability.”

 

The text of the law originated in the coalition’s drafting committee and was taken by Councilmembers Dan Kalb and Noel Gallo, who changed parts of it to deal with political realities in City Hall.

 

The final measure is not everything that the Coalition wanted but it does the essential job–it represents the Coalition’s vision of a strong and independent civilian oversight body.

 

Measure LL will create the Oakland Police Commission and the Community Police Review Agency. There will be seven volunteer commissioners, three chosen directly by the mayor and four chosen by a Selection Panel made up of City Council member appointees.

 

No current or former sworn member of the OPD or officer of the police union can be a police commissioner.

 

This process was designed by the coalition to insulate the commission from political considerations as much as possible.

 

The Oakland Police Commission will most likely be the only police oversight body in the country where the majority of whose members are not directly appointed by politicians.

 

The agency will investigate civilian complaints against police officers and recommend discipline to the commission.

 

The commission will have the power to discipline officers found guilty of misconduct and will also be able to review and change the OPD’s policies unless the City Council vetoes its action.

 

The commission will have the power to fire the police chief.

 

If Measure LL passes, Oakland will finally have a means of making the Police Department accountable to its residents. The Oakland Police Commission itself is not the destination of fair and constitutional policing.

 

That will still take constant citizen involvement. But it will be the vehicle to get us to that place.

 

Larry C. White is a volunteer attorney with the Coalition for Police Accountability.

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of November 18 – 24, 2026

Oakland Post: Week of November 18 – 24, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of November 11 -17, 2026

Oakland Post: Week of November 11 -17, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Community

Alameda County Supervisor Miley to Propose Illegal Dumping Ordinance

POST NEWS GROUP — The proposed ordinance would add Chapter 6.121 to the County’s General Ordinance Code, establishing an administrative enforcement process that would allow the County to hold more parties accountable without relying solely on criminal prosecution.

Published

on

At an unincorporated area cleanup in 2022, 10 tons of illegal dumping removed. Courtesy photo.

Proposal expands accountability, establishes administrative penalties, and ties fines to cleanup costs

On Tuesday, Nov. 17, the Alameda County Board of Supervisors is scheduled to consider the first reading of an ordinance proposed by Supervisor Nate Miley to strengthen enforcement against illegal dumping in unincorporated Alameda County, including Ashland, Cherryland, Castro Valley, San Lorenzo and Fairview.

Illegal dumping places a significant financial burden on residents and taxpayers. In 2024, Alameda County spent $3.8 million addressing 1,483 illegal dumping incidents, an average of approximately $2,562 per incident. Yet no illegal dumping cases from the unincorporated county were charged that year.

The proposed ordinance would add Chapter 6.121 to the County’s General Ordinance Code, establishing an administrative enforcement process that would allow the County to hold more parties accountable without relying solely on criminal prosecution.

Key provisions include:

  • Expanded accountability: Penalties could apply to individuals who dump waste, those who provide waste to unlicensed haulers who illegally dispose of it, and vehicle owners who knowingly consent to their vehicles being used for illegal dumping.
  • Administrative enforcement: Authorized County personnel could issue penalties and abatement orders, with opportunities for administrative hearings and judicial review.
  • Penalties tied to cleanup costs: Fines would start at $2,500 for a first violation, increase to $5,000 for a second and $10,000 for a third. Enhanced penalties of up to $10,000 per violation could apply to large-scale dumping, hazardous waste, or dumping near sensitive locations such as creeks, schools and storm drains.

The ordinance includes safeguards for people acting in good faith. Residents and businesses using licensed haulers would be exempt from waste-generator liability, while vehicle owners whose vehicles were used without their consent and property owners unaware of dumping on their land would also be protected.

Cited individuals could request community service in lieu of penalties, with ability to pay among the factors considered. The proposal would also allow property owners, business improvement districts and community groups to pursue recovery of cleanup costs and authorize the Board to establish a reward fund for tips identifying illegal dumpers.

“Every mattress and every truckload of construction debris dumped in Ashland, Cherryland and Castro Valley gets paid for by the people who live there, and right now the people responsible almost never face a consequence,” Miley said. “This ordinance closes the loopholes that let people hand off their waste and walk away. It gives the County a fair and swift way to hold dumpers accountable, protects people who do the right thing, and makes the penalty match what it costs us to clean up after them.”

Modeled on Santa Cruz County’s illegal dumping ordinance, which took effect in July 2025, the proposal was recommended for approval by the Board’s Unincorporated Services Committee.

Miley is also urging cities and counties throughout the region to adopt similar standards. His office has released a Model Illegal Dumping Enforcement Ordinance developed through the Alameda County Illegal Dumping (ACID) Task Force to support coordinated regional enforcement.

If the Board conducts the first reading on Nov. 17, the ordinance will return for adoption at a subsequent meeting and take effect 30 days after adoption.

Paul Sanftner is the director of communications and special projects for the office of Alameda County Supervisor Nate Miley.

Continue Reading

Subscribe to receive news and updates from the Oakland Post

CHECK OUT THE LATEST ISSUE OF THE OAKLAND POST

ADVERTISEMENT

Facebook

Trending

Copyright ©2021 Post News Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.