Connect with us

Opinion


Op Ed: There’s No Such Thing as a “Public Charter School”

Published

on

By Ann Berlak

 

This year, more than a quarter of Oakland’s 49,000 students are attending one of its nearly 40 charter schools, far more per capita than anywhere else in the state. 

Is this something for Oaklanders to boast about?

 

Not long ago I visited a school in Oakland to read to third graders on “Literacy Day.” On 
the way to the classroom I asked my guide if this was a charter or a public school. The 
immediate and decisive response: “We’re a public charter school.”

 

On June 14th the LA Times informed the public: “Charters are independently operated, free public schools.”

 

The California Department of Education makes no bones about it: “A charter school is a public school.”

 

However, the term “public charter school” was developed by a PR firm to reframe the way we understand schooling in relationship to “public” and to democracy.

 

The campaign has been wildly successful. However, though the term “public charter school” is increasingly ubiquitous, charters are not public schools.

 

Public institutions—schools, libraries, zoos—are, at least in theory, funded by 
taxes from all the people in its jurisdiction—local, state and national—and are held accountable to and by those people through that fundamental process we in a democracy call voting.

 

Most public schools are accountable to an elected school board made up of community 
members. Residents of that community have the right to be present at Board meetings, weigh in 
on votes and debates, and access public financial documents.

 

Charter schools are run by executive boards, committees or corporations whose members often 
live outside the community in which they are located and are not accountable to parents or 
the taxpayers/community members who fund them.

 

If you don’t like what your traditional public school is doing, you can make your voice heard by 
addressing administrators, voting for new leadership or taking a leadership role yourself. If 
you don’t like what your child’s charter school is doing and you express yourself, you may be 
asked to leave. There is no democratic mechanism for spearheading policy change.

 

Public institutions are the motors of democracy. Their purpose is to 
promote and preserve the fundamental values of a democratic society: liberty, equality and 
the public welfare or common good.

 

Public schools recognize that the welfare of everyone’s children and grandchildren is 
intimately linked to the welfare of all. Through support and oversight by the community, 
public schooling is intended to serve the common good and preserve fundamental qualities that sustain 
democracy beyond getting students “college and career ready.” If public schools have not always lived up to their promise then it is necessary to redouble our efforts to have them do so, not to abandon them.

 

When students leave public schools for charter schools they take their per pupil expenditures –which in California averaged $9,794 last year–with them, leaving public schools with less revenue but the same overhead.

 

The federal government also spends millions on charters at the expense of public schools. Taxpayers paid one consulting firm nearly $10 million to the U.S. Department of Education Charter Schools. That’s $10 million fewer federal dollars for public schools.

 

The law forbids local districts, which in California are the main authorizers for new charters, from taking into account the potentially crippling impact of new charters on district financing when considering approving new schools.

 

So even if you find an excellent charter to send your own child to, you are reducing the chances of every student remaining in the public school having their own excellent education.

 

Charter schools’ claim they enhance democracy is disingenuous.

 

The highly touted freedom of individual parents to choose their child’s school comes at the heavy price of reducing two other essential functions of democracy: providing for the general welfare of a society that requires well funded public schools and insuring equal opportunity for all children.

 

Competing with traditional public schools for space and funding reduces the quality of the remaining public schools, and ignores patterns of clear advantage for the children of savvy parents, thus assuring that some children will be better schooled than others.

 

Being publicly funded, charters cannot be considered private. However, their private governance and their marginalization of fundamental democratic values disqualify them as public.

 

The most accurate label for charters is “Publicly–funded private schools.” Don’t let them abscond with our language. There is no such thing as a public charter school.

 

Ann Berlak is an author and has worked as a teacher and teacher educator. She lives in Oakland.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of October 28 – November 3, 2026

Oakland Post: Week of October 28 – November 3, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of October 21 – 27, 2026

Oakland Post: Week of October 21 – 27, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of October 14 – 20, 2026

Oakland Post: Week of October 14 – 20, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Subscribe to receive news and updates from the Oakland Post

CHECK OUT THE LATEST ISSUE OF THE OAKLAND POST

ADVERTISEMENT

Facebook

At an unincorporated area cleanup in 2022, 10 tons of illegal dumping removed. Courtesy photo.
Community8 hours ago

Alameda County Supervisor Miley to Propose Illegal Dumping Ordinance

Protesters rallied against data centers outside Oakland city hall in September. Photo courtesy Saumya Roy/Al Jazeera.
Uncategorized8 hours ago

Oakland City Council Extends AI Data Center Moratorium for 10 Months.

U.S. Rep. Lateefah Simon. File photo.
Community9 hours ago

On Veterans Day, U.S. Rep. Simon Demands Answers on Status of Veterans Affairs Clinic, Columbarium Project

Pamela Price served as Alameda County District Attorney from 2023 to 2024. Courtesy photo.
Commentary9 hours ago

OPINION: Mario Juarez’s Courtroom Admissions Raise Questions About Allegations That Fueled Recall of Pamela Price

Education9 hours ago

Hutchinson Concedes: Ballots Still Being Counted in Oakland Board Elections

Barbara Lee and Denise Saddler, Courtesy photos.
Education9 hours ago

Mayor Lee and Schools’ Supt. Saddler Issue Joint Statement on Recent ICE Activity in Oakland

Mississippi Congressman Bennie G. Thompson. Wikipedia image.
Uncategorized9 hours ago

Mississippi Congressman Bennie Thompson Congratulates Scott Colom on Historic Victory

Pernell Johnson, left, received the crown and a cash prize for her sweet potato pie in the 2025 contest as Zakia Nazeen looks on. Courtesy photo.
Business9 hours ago

Farms to Grow, Inc. Hosts the 8th Annual Sweet Potato Pie Tasting Contest

File photo.
Economy1 week ago

How the Sandwich Generation Can Help Protect Aging Parents’ Finances

Barbara Lee. File photo.
Education1 week ago

As Progressive Democrats Celebrate ‘Blue Tsunami,’ Oakland Counts Victories

“We’re so proud,” said Mayor Barbara Lee who donned a violet wig on Wednesday at a rally honoring the Golden State Valkyries as the team celebrated its historic 2026 WNBA Championship in Oakland. Photo courtesy of NBC.
Community1 week ago

Golden State Valkyries Become Bay Area Legends Winning WNBA Championship on Halloween Night

Marcia Ann Gillespie. Facebook photo.
Black History1 week ago

IN MEMORIAM: Marcia Ann Gillespie, Editor of Essence and Ms. Magazines, Dies at 82

Some of the Congressional Women of the Year. Photo courtesy of Congressmember John Garamendi's office.
Black History1 week ago

U.S. Rep. John Garamendi Honors local ‘Women of the Year’ at Annual Awards Ceremony

A pantry at 34th street and Roosevelt avenue in Richmond. Photo courtesy of Achala Jayagoda.
Community1 week ago

Richmond Neighbors Put Pantry Power on the Map

Cutting the ribbon at the California Chamber of Commerce (CHCC) last month were CHCC Northern Region Director Mayra Perez, Aliza Gallo, Oakland Latino Chamber President CHCC Foundation Chairman David Betancourt, CHCC Madam Chair Veronica Corona, CHCC President & CEO Julian Canete and CHCC Northern Region Chair Leo Callejas. Courtesy photo.
Business1 week ago

Oakland Latino Chamber of Commerce Hosts Statewide Convention, Generating $3 Million in Economic Impact

Trending

Copyright ©2021 Post News Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.