Bay Area

School District Defends, Community Condemns Arrests of Parents and Teachers at School Board Meeting

Published

7 years ago

October 31, 2019

The Board of Education and administration of the Oakland Unified School District (OUSD) are facing a barrage of public criticism after the arrest and injury of six parents and teachers who were protesting at the last school board meeting against the district’s unwillingness to reconsider plans to close or “consolidate” a large number of schools in the coming years.

School officials, speaking at a press conference the day after the arrests, defended the police action as necessary to protect board meetings from disruption to and reaffirmed their commitment to close schools in order to “right size” the district.

Parents and teachers have demonstrated at the previous two school board meetings, forcing the board to move its meetings to a private room without public access. The protests were against school closures that are taking place and the wave of closings that are planned in the next three years. Since 2003, the district has closed 18 schools, 14 of which have become charters. The district has already set up an official school committee to authorize the sale and lease of closed school properties.

Amid huge parent and student protests and a successful school boycott, Roots Academy was closed in early 2019. The board also recently voted to shut down the Kaiser Elementary School campus and Oakland SOL at the end of the 2019 school year. Members of the “Oakland Not for Sale” coalition were ready to commit civil disobedience.

When people arrived at the Oct. 23 board meeting, they saw the board on stage, 29 OUSD police and school security officers stretched in a line in front of the stage and a line of metal police barricades and a line of barricades in front of them. When some parents and teachers attempted to pass through the barricades, they were knocked to the ground and arrested. Some were injured. Five of the arrestees were taken to the OUSD police station at Cole Elementary in West Oakland, cited and released. The sixth arrestee, Kaiser Elementary parent Saru Jayaraman, was taken to a hospital for treatment, cited and released.

Jayaraman, standing on crutches and wearing a leg brace, spoke at a vigil of about 150 teachers and families at the district headquarters in downtown Oakland. There, they opposed school closures and the violent arrests of members of the school community.

“We have gone to three or four school board meetings…with musical instruments, with guitars, with song sheets … and our demands. Those are the weapons we have carried,” she said. And when we walked in on Wednesday with our guitar and our signs and our banners, we were faced with cops who had batons and guns metal barricades — at a public school board meeting with children present. So, I ask you — who is dangerous? The people with signs (who sang) “We shall overcome” or the police who have batons and guns and the school board that directed them to attack us?”

Speaking at the OUSD press conference, District spokesman John Sasaki said, “Going into (Wednesday) night’s meeting, we wanted to be prepared to prevent disruption from happening once again. In an abundance of caution, we decided to protect the Board of Education and staff and to protect the students. We set up a barricade and we had security.”

“Some people began to rush the barrier,” said Sasaki. “For those people on the dais, it wasn’t clear what the goal (of the protesters) was, but it was a highly charged moment. At that point we moved the meeting upstairs and continued. “

OUSD Police Chief Jeff Godown said, “They were there with full intention to commit the crime. You cannot commit the crime. You cannot shut down the meeting.”

Condemning the arrests, California Teachers Association President E. Toby Boyd issued a statement:

“CTA condemns the heinous acts of violence perpetuated Oct. 23 by OUSD police officers against Oakland parents, student and educators who were peacefully protesting proposed school closures. There is no room for these actions in our schools or anywhere in society. We hold responsible the OUSD and supt. Kyla Johnson-Trammell for creating the atmosphere that led to police officers wildly swinging batons at unarmed teachers, parents and student, causing physical injury and emotional distress.”

A statement by Justice 4 Oakland Students (J4OS), a coalition of students, families and teachers, said:

“Using barricades and police violence to silence community voices and harming young people is unacceptable…This is a travesty that the OUSD Board perpetuates and models this use of excessive policing.

“(J4OS) stands against … the OUSD police presence and force ordered by the OUSD Board of Education against students, parents, teachers, and community members who were there to participate in the democratic process, including non-violent protest and disruption. It is our right to speak out and express dissenting opinions and demands in a public forum without the fear of police repression. We demand that the Superintendent and School Board apologize for the barricade created at a pub We demand that you commit to no use of OUSD or OPD Police or barricades at Board Meetings.”