Connect with us

Opinion

‘Failure to Supervise’ Goes All the Way to the Top

Published

on

By Erica Garner, Huffington Post

 

 

My father, Eric Garner, was killed by New York Police Department officer Daniel Pantaleo a year and a half ago, but last week marks the department’s first official charge of wrongdoing in his case.

 

 

The charge was not made against Pantaleo, the officer who placed my father in a fatal — and illegal — chokehold, but against Sgt. Kizzy Adonis, one of two supervising officers at the scene.

 

 

We know Sgt. Adonis wasn’t even assigned on patrol during the incident. According to Ed Mullins, head of the sergeants’ union, she “responded at her own initiative.”

 

 

She wasn’t the borough or zone commander. Yet Sgt. Adonis, stripped of her gun and badge, is now being charged on four counts of “failure to supervise.”

 

 

Though I never find myself agreeing with Mullins, a pathetic imitation of Pat Lynch, we share this opinion: The charges against Adonis are ridiculous.

 

 

Adonis, who was promoted to sergeant two weeks before my dad’s death, wasn’t part of the team that piled on his back. In the video that captured the incident, we all see Adonis creep away.

 

What we didn’t see? She went to the ambulance stationed on the corner of Bay Street. According to witnesses at the scene, Adonis spoke to an EMT and made an additional call for assistance — I guess no one else planned on saving my father’s life that day.

 

So why is Sgt. Adonis the only one facing charges? One guess: like my father, Sgt. Adonis is black.

 

We know black police officers can feel like outsiders within the force. We know that black officers in Chicago are punished more than twice as often as white ones.

 

 

Sgt. Adonis witnessed an incident of anti-black police brutality, one that would inspire protests around the world, and had to hold her composure among her white colleagues. I can only imagine what was going through her mind.

 

 

The manager of Bay Beauty Supply heard Sgt. Adonis say to the other officers, “Let up, you got him already.” Maybe she knew her day was coming. Maybe it was just a matter of time.

 

If Sgt. Adonis can be charged with failure to supervise, then I expect the other sergeant at the scene to be charged as well.

 

Charge the zone commander. Charge the borough commander. Charge the Police Commissioner. Charge the Mayor. Our entire political system justifies the murder of black citizens, and the “failure to supervise” goes all the way to the top.

 

Look at Freddie Gray’s case. Look at Sandra Bland’s. Instead of transparency and accountability, we get wrist slaps and scapegoating — and make no mistake, the charges against Sgt. Adonis are no more than this.

 

 

We can’t be satisfied with these meaningless actions. If we want true accountability for racist state violence, we’ll need to raise our voices and call out these moves for what they really are: failure to protect, failure to serve and failure to lead.

 

 

After a grand jury failed to indict the officers responsible for 12-year-old Tamir Rice’s death, his mother, Samaria Rice, laid the matter out plain and simple:

 

 

“Due to the corrupt system, I have a dead child.”

 

We need leaders willing to call out the corruption of our criminal justice system and clean it top-to-bottom. This year, as candidates run for local and national offices, we’ll hear them claim black lives matter. They’ll promise change. They’ll do their best to win over black and brown voters longing for justice. Then, once elected, they’ll turn their backs on us and uphold the same corrupt status quo.

 

Not me.

 

If I run for congress, I guarantee full transparency and accountability. It’s time to step up and become the leaders we’ve been waiting for. It’s time we stopped demanding justice from others and started creating it for ourselves. For Freddie Gray. For Sandra Bland. For Tamir Rice. For Eric Garner. Who’s with me?

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of September 23 – 29, 2026

The printed Weekly Edition of the Oakland Post: Week of September 23 – 29, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of September 16 – 22, 2026

The printed Weekly Edition of the Oakland Post: Week of September 16 – 22, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Activism

Oakland Post: Week of September 9 – 15, 2026

The printed Weekly Edition of the Oakland Post: Week of September 9 – 15, 2026

Published

on

To enlarge your view of this issue, use the slider, magnifying glass icon or full page icon in the lower right corner of the browser window.

Continue Reading

Subscribe to receive news and updates from the Oakland Post

* indicates required

CHECK OUT THE LATEST ISSUE OF THE OAKLAND POST

ADVERTISEMENT

Facebook

Assemblymember Corey Jackson (D-Moreno Valley). File photo.
Community2 days ago

Asm. Corey Jackson Announces Launch of 24-Hour Childcare in His District

The Rev. Leon “Sonny” Clark. File photo.
Black History2 days ago

IN MEMORIAM: The Rev. Leon “Sonny” Clark, Longtime Orange County Pastor and Community Leader, Dies at 72

Democrat Xavier Becerra and Republican Steve Hilton.
Economy2 days ago

Poll: Becerra Widens His Lead Over Hilton; Californians Split on Wealth Tax

Quixote Atkins of VillageGIVE moderates a panel discussion at the Coliseum 60 celebration at Youth UpRising featuring Keith Brown, a member of IATSE Local 107; author, historian and former Black Panther Party member Tareka Lewis; and African American Sports and Entertainment Group President Ray Bobbitt.
Business2 days ago

From Historic Memories to New Possibilities: Oakland Celebrates Coliseum 60

ACOE Supt. Alysse Castro; OUSD Supt. Dr. Denise Saddler. File photos.
Business2 days ago

County Office of Education Says OUSD Finances Are Getting Healthier, Materially Stronger

Imani Social Justice Team (left to right): Angela Noel, Zakiya Jendayi and Diane Doss. Patty Hallm, Susan Burns, Diane Lewis, Pastor Michael McBride, Theresa ???, Jean Moses and Diana Bell. Front: Sloane Johnson and (man whose name I'm getting to complete the identification). Photo by Octavian Kelly.
Community2 days ago

LIVE FREE Sunday Dinner Brings Faith, Fellowship and Civic Conversation to Oakland

Chancey Bailey. File photo.
Black History2 days ago

Remembering Chauncey Bailey as Student Journalists Face Threats to Truth-Telling

The first cohort of BLACspace participants with awards in August. Courtesy photo.
Art2 days ago

BLACspace Cooperative Invites Bay Area to Experience Oakland’s Black Cultural Ecosystem Through a BLAC Map Tour + Party

Oakland Police and emergency vehicle arrive to Williams Chapel Monday morning. Courtesy photo.
Black History2 days ago

In Wake of Death on Doorstep, Williams Chapel Baptist Church Calls for Better Care, Funding for Unhoused

Standing by her birthday cake, Nuna McKee waves to family and friends who came from far and near to celebrate her birthday. Courtesy photo.
Community2 days ago

Oakland Centenarian Nuna McKee Honored!

Bussa Emancipation Statue in Bridgetown, Barbados. Photo courtesy Wikimedia Commons.
Black History2 days ago

Caribbean Nations Produce Action Plan Calling for UK Reparations Over Slavery

Activism2 days ago

Oakland Post: Week of September 23 – 29, 2026

Long Beach resident Cassandra Carter approached the birth of her daughter, Nyomi (pictured), last November with anxiety after losing twins. She is pictured here with her husband.
Black History5 days ago

Doulas Are Helping Black California Moms Navigate Pregnancy–Even as High Mortality Rates Persist

iStock
Business1 week ago

Newsom Signs Addictive Social Media Law to Protect Kids

Shutterstock
Featured1 week ago

On Your November Ballot: Prop 38 Would Allocate $8.4 Billion to Immunology and Immunotherapy Funding

View of downtown Oakland, California and City Hall. iStock photo.
Community1 month ago

Four Candidates, Including Incumbent Barbara Lee, Qualify for Oakland Mayor’s Race

Commentary1 month ago

Standoff for Justice: Our Homes Are Worth Fighting For

Activism1 month ago

Oakland Post: Week of August 26 – September 1, 2026

Ribbon cutting ceremony and celebration at Terminal 1, Gate 3 of Frontier Airlines at Oakland San Francisco Bay Airport. (L-R) Port of Oakland Executive Director Kristi McKenney, U.S. Representative Congresswoman Lateefah Simon (D-CA-12), Oakland Mayor Barbara Lee, Frontier Airlines Vice President of Public and Consumer Affairs Tyri Squyres, Oakland Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce president Barbara Leslie, and Port of Oakland Board President Stephanie Dominguez Walton. Photo by Carla Thomas
Business1 month ago

Frontier Airlines’ Return to Oakland Airport Brings Flights, Jobs and Opportunity

Gubernatorial Candidate Steve Hilton. File photo.
Business1 month ago

Gubernatorial Candidate Steve Hilton Blasts California New Tire Rules; Newsom Hits Back

San Francisco Chef Sharon Lee, culinary educator and owner of The Spot! Photo courtesy of Chef Sharon Lee.
Business4 weeks ago

Chef Sharon Lee Blends Culinary Excellence, Education and Empowerment

Jackie Wright of Wright Enterprises. Photo courtesy of Wright Enterprises.
Black History4 weeks ago

Jackie Wright Champions Bay Area Stories, Filmmakers and Cultural Institutions

Local and state officials gathered at the State Capitol on Aug. 18 to discuss Proposition 1, a statewide bond measure that would fund housing and homelessness programs. Oakland Mayor Barbara Lee urged voters to approve the measure on the November ballot. Pictured to Lee’s right are Assemblymember Buffy Wicks (D-Oakland), Sacramento Mayor Kevin McCarty and Sen. Christopher Cabaldon (D-West Sacramento). CBM photo by Antonio Ray Harvey.
Community4 weeks ago

Big City Mayors Ask for “Yes” Vote on Housing Bond Measure; Conservatives Say “No”

Michael Love. File photo.
Education1 month ago

Gov. Newsom’s Latest Appointees Include Sacramento Advocate for Formerly Incarcerated Students; State’s New Tech Chief

Business1 month ago

Oakland Coliseum Project Opens Door for Small Businesses to Build Bigger

Parents, students, and teachers fought to save Roots International Academy, an East Oakland middle school that was closed in 2019 despite broad community opposition. Photo courtesy of Oakland North.
Community2 weeks ago

Misnamed ‘Parent’ PAC Seeks to Influence Oakland School Board Elections

Post Co-Publisher Gay Plair Cobb with Brendalynn Goodall. Courtesy photo.
Business4 weeks ago

Longtime BWOPA Member Brendalyn Goodall Appointed to California Workforce Development Board 

Asm. Mia Bonta (D-Oakland)
Community4 weeks ago

Gov. Newsom Signs Law Shielding Immigration Aid Workers From Doxing Threats

California Secretary of State Shirley Weber’s appearance at the UC Student and Policy Center drew a diverse audience. Weber, California’s chief elections officer, discussed election administration, voting by mail and national debates over election integrity. CBM photo by Antonio Ray Harvey.
Community1 month ago

Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber Urges Californians to Vote Early as Voter ID Battle Intensifies

Documentary film, "Seeds for Liberation," highlights the Palestinian struggle and the shared fight for freedom and liberation in the United States and abroad. Graphic courtesy of www.seedsforliberationmovie.com
Commentary1 month ago

From Palestine to Oakland: Seeds for Liberation Examines Shared Struggles for Freedom

Trending

Copyright ©2021 Post News Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.