Connect with us

Berkeley

OP-ED: Journalism in the Best Interest of the Child

Published

on

By Daniel Heimpel

A fortnight ago, the appeals court for the Second Appellate District in California invalidated a court order that had eased media access to Los Angeles County’s otherwise closed juvenile dependency hearings.

This ends two years of intermittent sunshine on the complicated functioning’s of the largest child welfare system in the nation, and perhaps the world.

The appeals court decision hinges on how much discretion a judge should have in barring reporters, and has reignited the long-simmering debate about the costs and benefits of allowing reporters to be present at hearings where minors fates are decided.

While the March 3 ruling seemingly closed the door on the media, it also sets up the possibility of two developments: an appeal to the California State Supreme Court, or new legislation allowing greater media access to dependency proceedings not only in Los Angeles, but across the state.

In my opinion, the dispute could and should be resolved through legislation that promotes a new, higher journalism: one practiced in the best interest of the child. .

A Judge’s Discretion and the Burden of Proof

 

In February of 2012, a week after Michael Nash, the Presiding Judge of Los Angeles’ Juvenile Court, had issued his now invalidated order, a reporter and a lawyer from the Los Angeles Times showed up at a hearing involving a 15-year-old girl and her four younger siblings. The girl had been removed from her parents by the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) after her father had allegedly committed “brutal domestic violence” against her and her mother.

It was a tense and uncertain time at the Edelman Children’s Court in Monterey Park California, a sprawling labyrinth of court-rooms and offices set atop a hill where judges and lawyers change the life trajectories of as many as 30,000 children a year. Like many other juvenile courts that had allowed press in, the first few weeks of openness in Los Angeles were met with a herd of reporters keen on easy access.

The courts are already chaotic. Children, like A.L. and her siblings, are not alone in the hearing rooms. Attorneys, bailiffs, court referees, clerks, guardians ad litem and an intermittent cast of family members and social workers are all part of the swirling tide of professionals, paraprofessionals and consumers that make up the county’s vast child welfare system.

The Children’s Law Center of California (CLC) represents every child in Los Angeles County: its 100 lawyers average a caseload of 300 each. From the start, CLC had opposed media access. And in those strange days after Nash issued his order, CLC attorneys were throwing up objections to almost any journalist in the room.

It was through her CLC lawyer that A.L. objected to the Times’ presence.

Almost a month later, the judge in A.L.’s case ruled that the Times would be allowed into the court-room, despite CLC’s assertion that “the child is at an age (15) where children are extremely sensitive to the possibility of their private information being disseminated to others.”

A.L.’s lawyers filed a writ to override the court’s decision, which was denied, setting it up for appeal and the decision in A.L.’s favor published on March 3.

That decision hinges on the concept of judicial discretion and burden of proof. Judge Nash’s order compelled court referees to allow the press in, and only force them out if someone could show a “reasonable likelihood that such access will be harmful to the children’s best interest.”

In his original order, Nash cited the California Welfare and Institutions Code (which governs the dependency system) and two cases – Brian W. v. Superior Court and San Bernardino County Dept. of Public Social Services v. Superior Court – which both dealt with media access to juvenile proceedings.

In 1991, the San Bernardino Sun newspaper requested access to the juvenile court records and files of a sibling group, which had been removed from their home under awful, headline-grabbing circumstances. The attorneys for the siblings objected. Ultimately the court denied the Sun access to the records, but used its discretion to admit the reporter to the hearing under certain conditions.

The appellate court struck down that ruling, but clarified the law around media access significantly:

“Members of the press are persons having a direct and legitimate interest in the work of the court and may be permitted to attend such proceedings in the juvenile court’s discretion under Welfare and Institutions Code Section 346.”

The problem is that Section 346 can be read both as exclusionary and inclusionary to the press. The section reads:

“Unless requested by a parent or guardian and consented or requested by the minor concerning whom the petition has been filed, the public shall not be admitted to a juvenile court hearing.” But, “the judge or referee may nevertheless admit such persons as he deems to have a direct and legitimate interest in the particular case or work of the court.”

While, A.L. had a reasonable objection to the Los Angeles Times presence during the February 2012 hearing, and the Times’ attorney and reporter may have shown insensitivity by not respecting her wishes, it is unclear where judicial discretion had been infringed upon. The judge in that courtroom had the ultimate discretion to either uphold or deny the objection.

The appellate decision seems to argue that the overall environment of the court, where the presiding judge had issued an order bending the culture towards openness, was one where individual court referees were inhibited from exercising the discretion that code section and case law give them.

“We agree that press attendance at dependency proceedings may be allowed, and that the legislature intended to encourage it, as Brian W. tells us,” the majority wrote in this month’s opinion. “But both Brian W. and San Bernardino are also clear that press admittance to dependency hearings involves an exercise of the juvenile court’s discretion in the context of the unique facts of each case.”

Further, the majority opinion looks to shift the burden of proof on access back to the press.

“The press must ultimately persuade the court that the balance of competing interests should be weighed in its favors – that is, there is no reasonable likelihood that access will be harmful to the child’s best interests.”

It is on this question, the likelihood of harm to a child, that the entire debate falls, and where one can discern an opportunity to bridge the gap between needed privacy for child victims and the social change transparency can bring.

Cross posted with the Chronicle of Social Change. Read the full story here.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Activism

Black Repertory Group Needs Volunteers to Help Shape the Next Generation of Artists and Leaders

Legendary performers such as Whoopi Goldberg and Danny Glover worked with and were inspired by BRG’s founders. More recently, Grammy award-winning artist Kehlani attended the Black Repertory Group Summer Day Camp for several years.

Published

on

Courtesy image.
Courtesy image.

By Sean Vaughn Scott, Special to The Post

For more than 60 years, the Black Repertory Group (BRG) has changed lives through the arts.

Founded in 1964 by educators and visionaries Birel L. Vaughn and Nora Vaughn, BRG has become one of America’s oldest continuously operating Black theater institutions. For generations, it has preserved culture, developed talent, and provided opportunities for young people to discover their voices and their potential.

The results speak for themselves.

Legendary performers such as Whoopi Goldberg and Danny Glover worked with and were inspired by BRG’s founders. More recently, Grammy award-winning artist Kehlani attended the Black Repertory Group Summer Day Camp for several years.

Long before international recognition, Kehlani performed on the BRG stage. During a summer day camp production of  “Princess and da Frog,” she portrayed Ray, the lovable firefly whose light guided others through the darkness. Her journey is proof that today’s camper may become tomorrow’s artist, entrepreneur, educator, or leader.

Located at 3201 Adeline St. in Berkeley, BRG continues that mission through its Youth Summer Day Camp of the Arts.

BRG is currently accepting applications and maintains an open enrollment program. Students may enroll throughout the summer as space permits and immediately become part of the BRG family.

We are also proud to be a multicultural opportunity program, welcoming children and families from all backgrounds, cultures, and communities. Through theater, music, dance, public speaking, visual arts, technical theater, and leadership development, students gain confidence, discipline, creativity, and lifelong skills.

As our programs grow, so does our need for volunteers.

We are seeking community members to assist with youth mentoring, registration, costumes, set construction, painting, props, ushering, photography, social media, marketing, technical theater, and fundraising activities. Whether you volunteer for a few hours or throughout the season, your support directly impacts the lives of young people.

BRG also partners with churches, civic organizations, alumni associations, fraternities, sororities, and community groups through theater party fundraisers, group sales, and buy-out performances. These partnerships have helped organizations raise funds while supporting arts and cultural programming.

The theater also serves as the home of the Berkeley NAACP Chapter, which meets every second Saturday of the month from 1 to 3 p.m.

For more than six decades, the Black Repertory Group has remained committed to one belief: every child deserves an opportunity to shine.

The next great artist may already be among us.

The next Kehlani may already be walking through our doors.

We invite you to volunteer, enroll, participate, and become part of the legacy.

For more information please go to www.blackrepertorygroup.com, call (510) 652-2120, or email info@blackrepertorygroup.com

Sean Vaughn Scott is the director of the Black Repertory Group.

Continue Reading

Bay Area

UC Berkeley Named Top Public University in the U.S. and No. 7 in the World by ‘U.S. News’

Berkeley has been consistently awarded the distinction of the U.S.’s top public university since the Best Global Universities list was first published in 2014. “A strong position in the Best Global Universities rankings recognizes a school’s profound commitment to world-class research and cross-border academic excellence,” said LaMont Jones, managing editor for education at U.S. News.

Published

on

Photo by Keegan Houser/UC Berkeley.
Photo by Keegan Houser/UC Berkeley.

The 2026 Best Global Universities rankings evaluated 2,250 research institutions from more than 100 countries

By Lila Thulin

U.S. News & World Report has ranked UC Berkeley No. 7 in its 2026 list of the best global universities, which assesses more than 2,250 research institutions worldwide.

Berkeley also claimed the honor of top public university in the U.S.

Released on Monday, the list evaluates universities from more than 100 countries on 13 metrics such as global and research reputation (as reported by academics and peers) and number of highly cited scholarly papers.

Berkeley has been consistently awarded the distinction of the U.S.’s top public university since the Best Global Universities list was first published in 2014.

“A strong position in the Best Global Universities rankings recognizes a school’s profound commitment to world-class research and cross-border academic excellence,” said LaMont Jones, managing editor for education at U.S. News.

The rankings also assess a university’s strength in various subject areas; these assessments are separate from U.S. News’ 2026 Best Graduate Programs rankings released in April.

This year, Berkeley was named in the top three nationally in seven subject areas – environment/ecology, ecology, water resources, physics, computer science, chemistry, and engineering – and in the top five for a total of 17 subjects. Subject rankings are based heavily on scholarly publications and citations as well as reputation.

In September, U.S. News also released its 2026 Best Colleges list, in which Berkeley was also named the No. 1 public institution among American universities.

That honor joins other accolades judging campus to be the best public university in the country, such as those from Forbes, The Wall Street Journal and Times Higher Education.

Continue Reading

Arts and Culture

Farwest Region Deltas Celebrate Centennial With “September Breakfast” Honoring Vivian Osborne Marsh

The region was established in 1925 under the leadership of Vivian Osborne Marsh, who became its first Regional Director. Marsh was a pioneering scholar and civic leader, earning recognition as the first Black woman to receive both a bachelor’s and a master’s degree in anthropology from UC Berkeley.

Published

on

Farwest Regional Director, Kimberly Usher, Mayor Barbara Lee, US Representative Lateefah Simon, and Farwest Regional Representative, Radiya Ajibade. Photo courtesy of Farwest Regional Photographer Vicki P. Love.
Farwest Regional Director, Kimberly Usher, Mayor Barbara Lee, US Representative Lateefah Simon, and Farwest Regional Representative, Radiya Ajibade. Photo courtesy of Farwest Regional Photographer Vicki P. Love.

By Antoinette Porter

Hundreds of members of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc., and their guests gathered at the Martin Luther King Jr. Student Union at the University of California, Berkeley, to mark the 100th anniversary of the sorority’s Farwest Region.

The region was established in 1925 under the leadership of Vivian Osborne Marsh, who became its first Regional Director. Marsh was a pioneering scholar and civic leader, earning recognition as the first Black woman to receive both a bachelor’s and a master’s degree in anthropology from UC Berkeley.

Marsh went on to serve as Delta Sigma Theta’s 7th National President, where she launched the sorority’s National Library Project to expand access to books in underserved Black communities in the South. During her presidency, the organization also became a prominent voice in the civil rights movement, lobbying Congress to pass anti-lynching legislation.

Bak in the Bay Area, Marsh devoted her career to advancing educational opportunities, mentoring young people, and strengthening community life. That commitment continues to shape the region, which supports initiatives in education, social justice, and economic development. Current projects include raising scholarship funds for students at Historically Black Colleges and Universities, voter education campaigns, and health and wellness programs.

A century after its founding, the Farwest Region of Delta Sigma Theta remains active across California and other western states, carrying forward Marsh’s vision of service and advocacy.

Continue Reading

Subscribe to receive news and updates from the Oakland Post

CHECK OUT THE LATEST ISSUE OF THE OAKLAND POST

ADVERTISEMENT

Facebook

At an unincorporated area cleanup in 2022, 10 tons of illegal dumping removed. Courtesy photo.
Community8 hours ago

Alameda County Supervisor Miley to Propose Illegal Dumping Ordinance

Protesters rallied against data centers outside Oakland city hall in September. Photo courtesy Saumya Roy/Al Jazeera.
Uncategorized8 hours ago

Oakland City Council Extends AI Data Center Moratorium for 10 Months.

U.S. Rep. Lateefah Simon. File photo.
Community8 hours ago

On Veterans Day, U.S. Rep. Simon Demands Answers on Status of Veterans Affairs Clinic, Columbarium Project

Pamela Price served as Alameda County District Attorney from 2023 to 2024. Courtesy photo.
Commentary9 hours ago

OPINION: Mario Juarez’s Courtroom Admissions Raise Questions About Allegations That Fueled Recall of Pamela Price

Education9 hours ago

Hutchinson Concedes: Ballots Still Being Counted in Oakland Board Elections

Barbara Lee and Denise Saddler, Courtesy photos.
Education9 hours ago

Mayor Lee and Schools’ Supt. Saddler Issue Joint Statement on Recent ICE Activity in Oakland

Mississippi Congressman Bennie G. Thompson. Wikipedia image.
Uncategorized9 hours ago

Mississippi Congressman Bennie Thompson Congratulates Scott Colom on Historic Victory

Pernell Johnson, left, received the crown and a cash prize for her sweet potato pie in the 2025 contest as Zakia Nazeen looks on. Courtesy photo.
Business9 hours ago

Farms to Grow, Inc. Hosts the 8th Annual Sweet Potato Pie Tasting Contest

File photo.
Economy1 week ago

How the Sandwich Generation Can Help Protect Aging Parents’ Finances

Barbara Lee. File photo.
Education1 week ago

As Progressive Democrats Celebrate ‘Blue Tsunami,’ Oakland Counts Victories

“We’re so proud,” said Mayor Barbara Lee who donned a violet wig on Wednesday at a rally honoring the Golden State Valkyries as the team celebrated its historic 2026 WNBA Championship in Oakland. Photo courtesy of NBC.
Community1 week ago

Golden State Valkyries Become Bay Area Legends Winning WNBA Championship on Halloween Night

Marcia Ann Gillespie. Facebook photo.
Black History1 week ago

IN MEMORIAM: Marcia Ann Gillespie, Editor of Essence and Ms. Magazines, Dies at 82

Some of the Congressional Women of the Year. Photo courtesy of Congressmember John Garamendi's office.
Black History1 week ago

U.S. Rep. John Garamendi Honors local ‘Women of the Year’ at Annual Awards Ceremony

A pantry at 34th street and Roosevelt avenue in Richmond. Photo courtesy of Achala Jayagoda.
Community1 week ago

Richmond Neighbors Put Pantry Power on the Map

Cutting the ribbon at the California Chamber of Commerce (CHCC) last month were CHCC Northern Region Director Mayra Perez, Aliza Gallo, Oakland Latino Chamber President CHCC Foundation Chairman David Betancourt, CHCC Madam Chair Veronica Corona, CHCC President & CEO Julian Canete and CHCC Northern Region Chair Leo Callejas. Courtesy photo.
Business1 week ago

Oakland Latino Chamber of Commerce Hosts Statewide Convention, Generating $3 Million in Economic Impact

Trending

Copyright ©2021 Post News Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.